[Entrepreneur Pulver v.
Battelle Memorial Institute PNNL]
Evidence Site: :
Patent Fraud, Misrepresenting
Inventions - Patent Fraud
Energy Dept. Funding Battelle to
Falsify Inventions and Conceal its Violating False Claims Act Again [Prior
Battelle Defrauding Patent Office, Small Business, Taxpayers, Federal Judge & Ninth Circuit Court of
USPTO Director Kappos refused to investigate Battelle's admitted patent fraud at the
• Battelle Misused DOE Small Business Tech. Assistance Program: Withheld / Pocketed Wireless Software for Ventures ← Violated False Claims Act
• Admitted to Incident and Practice of Defrauding Patent Office [USPTO]: Misrepresenting
Inventions to Reset/Evade Statutory Filing Deadlines
• Suborned Perjury [Falsified Inventions & Hid Ventures] by Scientist* Accessing Classified & Sensitive
Cargo Explosives, DOD…]
• DOE Fleecing Taxpayers Nearly
$1M: Investing in Perjury to Conceal Fraud & Security
Breach by Battelle that Received $500M
• Dr. Chu Soliciting
Entrepreneurs Under False Pretenses: Coaxing Them to License Inventions from Battelle [et al.] While Hiding its Fraud
• Chu Rewards Fraud by Extending 48-Year PNNL Contract; Inspector General Implicated
in Leaking Pulver/DOJ email to Battelle Legal
• Battelle defrauded
patent office and DOE Technical Assistance Program that funded developing Mobile
[MDM] software for
Pulver’s small business.
▪ On 8/29/03, it delivered non-working version and withheld working MDM software from him
who had worldwide exclusive license to market
& develop follow-on
Meanwhile, Battelle was illegally marketing
to Ecolab [Fortune 500] to license MDM as point-of-sale catalog for worldwide sales force. [Undercutting Pulver]
▪ It nominated working MDM version for R&D 100 Award, adapted to BlackBerry, suddenly called "new
code” [“so Pulver is toast”], wrote ‘NEW’ invention report [“RDADS”],
reset/evaded prior statutory filing deadlines & fraudulently applied for patent, and [admittedly] commercialized. → 2 sets of MDM versions exist: Working & Non-Working.
▪ Battelle implicates itself: Admitting it developed working versions 3 months before delivery, it asserts right to deliver unworkable version [“zero...less than a Barbie Doll”].
“ridiculous” and based on extensive evidence, judge denied
2008 motion to dismiss Pulver’s breach of contract claim [withholding working versions].
• Battelle documents, testimony & filings show perjury [Falsifying
Research & Hiding
Ventures] by developer Dorow to conceal patent fraud [falsifying inventions] & false claims.
Security Radiation Portal Monitor Project [RPMP] funded Battelle to adapt MDM to BlackBerry
▪ To hide evidence the actual MDM software worked, was enhanced [BlackBerry] and patented, Dorow & DOE-funded counsel misrepresenting
DHS research to the court.
▪ Battelle admits misrepresenting inventions to USPTO, e.g., 2005 patent application for RDADS
that’s actually the 2002 MDM inventions [w expired 2003 filing deadlines].
▪ Battelle falsely
denied funding development of commercial RDADS-RFID version [Cargo Security], wireless technology in which Battelle Ventures invested $15.5 Million.
Updates [e.g., DOE-Science funding research fraud (perjury) to cover up Battelle patent
fraud & illegally misusing
small business programs as feeders for its ventures. Taxpayer Cost: $900K ]
• 11/23/09 Email: DOE funding Battelle
PNNL rebid tainted;
DOE/Battelle v. SEC/Madoff; National security breach; Discrediting President's small business support.
• Jan. 2010 Emails to DOE Secretary Chu , DHS Sec. Napolitano,
Sec. Locke and Undersecretary Kappos [Director, US Patent &
Trademark Office]. [Battelle fraud]
9/23/10 Email: Greg Friedman [Inspector General] & USPTO [David Kappos] allow Battelle to continue admitted patent fraud at DOE labs [Falsifying inventions to evade filing deadlines.]
• 10/8/10 Email: Friedman shelving 7 years of fraud evidence [red flags] - Authorizes ongoing national
lab patent fraud & security breach, putting other entrepreneurs at risk.
• 11/3/11 Email: DOE Response to Defense Nuclear Facilities Safety Board Discredited: (1) Chu rewards Battelle fraud - Extends PNNL 48-year contract [Preempts bid protests
probe], (2) IG Investigations Office is complicit in perjury & leaking Pulver/DOJ docs. to Battelle legal team and (3) HSS [Health Safety
Security] ignored security breach.
• 11/30/11 Email to DOE & Board: Friedman complicity in concealing criminal misconduct against small business, patent office & court necessitates
the President fire him.
• 12/28/11 Email re: Senator McCaskill [Chairman, Subcommittee on Contracting Oversight] confirms DOE paying contractor
legal costs is retaliation; Battelle perjury is far
• 1/30/12 Public
Comment: USPTO should not award patent satellite office to Columbus OH, home of Battelle that admits to patent fraud. ← 7/2/12: USPTO rejects Ohio.
• 4/30/12 Email: DOE-IG Friedman is stonewalling/concealing after Investigations agent is
implicated in retaliating, colluding with and leaking Pulver/DOJ email to Battelle.
• 9/10/12 Email:
Council of Inspectors General on Integrity & Efficiency and OMB Director Zients are whitewashing Friedman's 9-year obstruction of justice & retaliation to
cover up repeat-offender Battelle defrauding entrepreneur, taxpayers & courts → Such
collusion is a warning for others to report agency fraud to Congress & avoid the IGs.